“CPA or MBA?” It’s a question many accounting professionals ask themselves as they consider how to best advance in their career. Candidates who are weighing these options typically have 2 to 10 years of experience and are first-tier management professionals, often with a Big 4 accounting firm background. They may have advanced to a new position but did not receive the increase in pay that they were hoping for, and see the CPA or MBA as a way to get them where they want to be.
Both designations can do wonders for a candidate’s career. The Master of Business Administration (MBA) differentiates you from other candidates by equipping you with a sought after and unique skillset. But it is a time-consuming endeavor, with many programs lasting 2 years or more. It can also be quite costly: the average tuition for a Top 50 MBA program in 2013 was $54,008. The Certified Public Accountant (CPA) certification is another great way to accelerate your career. It has a much lower cost and takes much less time to earn, but does not offer the same wide scope of knowledge an MBA does offer. Ultimately, the choice can be determined by what the candidate wants to accomplish in their career. These candidates generally fit into one of three categories: The Aspiring Controller/CFO, Corporate FP&A, and The Wall Streeter.
If a candidate’s goal is to become a CFO or Controller, it is wise to earn your CPA. A CPA aligns equips the candidate to meet the expected duties of a controller, but that aspiring CFO’s forgo the MBA in favor of a CPA reveals an exception to the commonly-held belief that entry to a C-level position requires an MBA. Traditionally, holding an MBA was a prerequisite to becoming a CFO, but that has changed along with in the role’s qualifications, catalyzed by the passing of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act in 2002. Now that Chief Financial Officers are charged with greater responsibility over the accuracy of a company’s reporting, companies refocused their CFO searches. Rather than looking for candidates with a “traditional” background in banking, private equity, and finance, more companies began selecting CFO’s coming from a controller position that required CPA licensure. Today the majority of CFO’s are also CPAs, with 61% of McLean-based companies have a CFO with a CPA.
The CPA doesn’t just offer candidates a better chance to attain their long-term career goals: there are considerable short-term benefits, as well.
The CPA designation is currently in very high demand for reasons that can also be attributed to Sarbanes-Oxley, with many companies implementing CPA quotas for hiring new candidates. A locally-based global multimedia company decided to restructure their internal audit shop, and ended up releasing their entire team in order to rebuild a team comprised entirely of CPAs. CPA holders enjoy higher wages than their accounting peers where it is estimated that post-CPA achievers earn 20% more annually and the gap between CPA holder and non-CPA holder pay only increases with time.
When it comes to corporate accounting and finance, if your company is willing to pay for it, or if you already have a CPA and are looking for another challenge, an MBA can definitely set you on the road to Controller or CFO role. But if you find yourself constricted by time or budget, your best course of action is suggested to be the CPA exam.
For those with more finance-oriented goals than an accounting focus, such as corporate FP&A and private equity. For these candidates it is they earn an MBA, but with a few caveats. If the company will pay for the MBA, you should certainly enroll in a program- but don’t expect a significant raise upon completion of the program. There are some cases in which completion of an MBA will result in increase in pay. For example, if you were looking to move into corporate finance, your company was willing to pay for the MBA, and you remained employed with them as you pursued your MBA, you would likely see an increase in pay upon completion of your degree. But candidates from global companies whose MBA was paid for, received, at most, a weak salary increase and no change in their base pay. However, when placed at a different company, it is possible to negotiate a 20-25% increase in their pay, due to having obtained an MBA.
The final subset is made up of professionals who are looking to make a career pivot into investment banking– The Wall Streeter. These candidates typically work in finance already, but their experience is not necessarily eye catching or particularly relevant to Wall Street firms. These same firms recruit heavily out of Top 20 MBA programs so if that path aligns with your desires make sure to chose a program with a track record for placements in Wall Street Firms.
Earning either one of these designations certainly will open doors– but they may not be the doors you were hoping would be opened. To ensure that you are optimally positioned in the job market, it’s important to carefully consider your career goals, budget, and the amount of time you have available to attain these accomplishment before you before committing to either a CPA or MBA. It is also a good idea to consult a recruiter to determine which one will best suit your aspirations. They will have a better understanding of what market demand is at that time as well as a more informed perspective on which title will best compliment your background and aspirations.